The sports media landscape, with outlets like ESPN, FS1, and other mainstream platforms, has often been under scrutiny for their coverage choices. A curious case arises when comparing their extensive coverage of figures like Deshaun Watson and Shannon Sharpe with their seemingly muted coverage of Justin Tucker, one of the NFL’s most iconic and consistent players. While both Watson and Sharpe have been the focus of endless debates, controversies, and media cycles, Tucker’s narrative seems to be largely ignored in the broader sports conversation. This discrepancy raises questions about how the media determines its coverage priorities and whether certain stories are simply more captivating or marketable than others.
1. The Allure of Controversy
One of the key factors that dictate sports media coverage is the presence of controversy. Deshaun Watson, for example, has been at the center of a massive media firestorm due to his legal issues, allegations of misconduct, and eventual trade to the Cleveland Browns. These types of stories, involving drama, legal battles, and public perception, generate clicks and stimulate conversation—an essential part of sports media’s business model. Media outlets can’t help but dive into these narratives, keeping them in the 24/7 news cycle. The debate about Watson’s character, his future in the NFL, and the public’s reaction to his actions has become a talking point on countless platforms.
In contrast, Justin Tucker is a figure who, for all his greatness, has avoided scandal or drama throughout his career. Tucker has set numerous NFL records, including the longest field goal in NFL history at 66 yards, and has been consistently regarded as one of the league’s most dependable players. However, his lack of personal or professional controversy means that Tucker’s story doesn’t naturally fit into the media’s preferred mold of high drama or controversy. While he may be discussed occasionally for his athletic prowess, his consistent professionalism doesn’t fuel the kind of explosive, opinionated discussions that drive media engagement.
2. The Cult of Personality and ‘Larger Than Life’ Characters
Shannon Sharpe, a Hall of Fame tight end, transitioned seamlessly into the media world, where his strong opinions and often bombastic personality allowed him to carve out a niche for himself. Sharpe’s frequent debates, high-profile feuds, and no-holds-barred commentary made him a frequent subject of sports news, especially on shows like Skip and Shannon: Undisputed on FS1. His persona—larger than life and unafraid of speaking his mind—grabs attention in a way that Justin Tucker’s quiet professionalism doesn’t.
Tucker’s personality, while respected and admired, is not one to stir controversy. He doesn’t engage in public spats, doesn’t have a notorious past, and rarely does anything that would draw negative attention to himself. In a media environment where “clicks” and “views” are king, the lack of a compelling backstory or explosive personality leaves Tucker as less of a media magnet. In contrast, Sharpe’s bombastic nature has become an integral part of his media presence. This explains, in part, why Sharpe has dominated sports conversations, while Tucker remains more of a background figure.
3. Media’s Focus on Quarterbacks and High-Profile Positions
Sports media has long prioritized quarterbacks and other high-profile positions, especially in the NFL. This stems from the way the league markets itself and the importance placed on the QB position in driving success for a team. Deshaun Watson, as a former Pro Bowl QB with significant contract value and a massive trade to Cleveland, is a natural subject for coverage due to the high stakes involved in his career trajectory.
Justin Tucker, as a kicker, is not in a position that traditionally garners the same level of media attention. While his performance is critical, it’s often seen as supplementary to the more visible roles on the field. Even though Tucker’s record-breaking kicks and game-winning moments are crucial to his team’s success, kickers often don’t receive the same level of sustained media coverage as other players in more prominent positions. Media outlets generally focus on quarterbacks, wide receivers, and defensive players because their performances directly affect the narrative of a game. The kicker’s moment often comes at the tail end of a match, when the spotlight isn’t necessarily on them.
4. The Modern Media Landscape and Its Priorities
In today’s media environment, platforms like ESPN and FS1 are in the business of drawing eyes, clicks, and views. The more sensational and contentious a story, the more likely it is to generate public discourse and be covered extensively. This is why stories involving Watson’s legal troubles or Sharpe’s outspoken commentary on various topics are more likely to dominate coverage. The need to feed the 24/7 news cycle with something that elicits strong opinions, debates, or controversy takes precedence.
Justin Tucker’s lack of drama doesn’t fit neatly into the narrative that drives modern sports media. The story of a kicker’s consistency, reliability, and records, while impressive to fans of the game, simply doesn’t spark the same type of mass media attention. Tucker’s excellence is quieter but no less valuable—he has perfected his craft in the shadows of higher-profile players and has become the embodiment of consistency and excellence. However, in an era where drama often trumps substance, media coverage often overlooks these more subtle, yet equally important, stories.
Conclusion
The media’s selective focus on figures like Deshaun Watson and Shannon Sharpe, while largely ignoring Justin Tucker’s historic career, speaks volumes about the direction sports media has taken. In a landscape driven by controversy, drama, and larger-than-life personalities, Tucker’s remarkable career as a kicker may simply not fit the mold. His lack of scandal, his quiet professionalism, and his position on the field may not generate the kind of explosive headlines that draw media attention. Yet, despite this, Tucker’s legacy as the most accurate kicker in NFL history deserves recognition, even if it’s not as widely celebrated in the mainstream sports media.
Leave a Reply